At a Glance: Best Concealed Carry Magazine Pouch
Comparison of Best Concealed Carry Magazine Pouch
Our Top Pick
|Tulster Universal 9mm/.40 Double Stack Mag Carrier Echo Carrier IWB/OWB||View Latest Price|
Our Top Pick
|TACwolf 2 Pack IWB EDC Magazine Pouch||View Latest Price|
Our Top Pick
|Universal Double Magazine Holster||View Latest Price|
As you might expect, I considered my firearm to be the most important piece of everyday carry gear. However, even the best pistol is useless without ammo. That is why I recommend carrying a spare magazine. It is important that you choose the best magazine pouch for your everyday carry so that you can comfortably and safely carry your backup magazine.
Our Guide to the 8 Best Magazine Pouches for CCW
Choosing the right pouch may seem like an easy decision. I mean it is just a magazine pouch, right? Actually, there is a little bit more to it than you might expect. A good EDC magazine pouch should offer some retention while also being comfortable and concealable. Finding the right pouch among the hundreds of options on the market can be challenging, which is why we compiled a list of the 8 best EDC pouches available today.
Tulster Universal 9mm/.40 Double Stack Mag Carrier Echo Carrier IWB/OWB
We will kick off our review with one of the best IWB magazine holsters on the list – an ultra-durable Kydex holster made by Tulster. This magazine pouch is designed to hold double-stack .40 caliber and 9mm magazines. The adjustable tension screws mean that it will hold your magazine in place while also keeping it ready to go when you need it.
I especially like this magazine pouch because of its versatility. It can be worn inside or outside the waistband. This magazine carrier is even reversible to accommodate both left and right-handed shooters. You would be surprised how hard it is to find stuff for southpaw’s, which is why I always appreciate a reversible design.
This Tulster mag carrier is available in 11 different finish options. It weighs in at less than two ounces and has an easy-to-use clip to attach to your belt or waistband.
- Durable Kydex
- Multiple Finish Options
- Adjustable tension
- Can accommodate 9mm or .40 caliber magazines
- Some finishes can be abrasive
- No single-stack option
- No .45 caliber option
TACwolf 2 Pack IWB EDC Magazine Pouch
If you are interested in a lighter and softer material, then our next pick may be just what you are looking for. The TACwolf IWB soft magazine pouches are comfortable and easy to use. As an added bonus, they include two mag pouches in case you prefer to carry two spare magazines.
They can accommodate a wide array of single and double stack magazines, making them one of the more versatile options on our list. However, I found that double-stack magazines provided the best fit and some retention. Micro or subcompact single stack magazines may fit somewhat loosely within these magazine pouches.
These pouches each weigh in at just over 1 ounce. They use a combination of neoprene and leather to make them resistant to sweat. They attach with a steel belt clip and come in only one color, black.
- Two Pouches Included
- Can accommodate single and double stack magazines
- Only one color option
- No adjustable tension
- Minimal retention with small, single-stack magazines
Universal Double Magazine Holster
Our third option serves as a happy medium between our first two picks. This Universal Double Magazine Holster is made from a durable polymer that is less abrasive than Kydex. It offers you the ability to carry two spare magazines while still providing you with adjustable tension, unlike the neoprene holsters.
This magazine holster is capable of accommodating a variety of double-stack magazines. It is designed to be used with or without a gun belt and is carried outside of the waistband. The paddle angle is adjustable in case you prefer to carry your magazines canted towards the front. This holster attaches to your waistband with an open-ended paddle, making for a comfortable fit.
This magazine holster is very lightweight, weighing in at approximately 2 ounces. It includes the needed Allen key to adjust the tension and the angle of the paddle clip. It is available in black only.
- Holds two magazines
- Fits most double stack magazines
- Good tension
- Comfortable to wear seated or standing
- One finish
- The open-ended attachment method is less secure than other methods
Relentless Tactical Leather Double Magazine Holder
Our next option also holds two spare magazines, but it does so while sporting a classic look. The Relentless Tactical Leather magazine holder is made in the USA and includes a lifetime warranty that is tough to beat. The quality of craftsmanship is apparent as soon as you take it out of the box.
This leather magazine pouch offers great retention while also maximizing comfort. It is available in a single stack or double stack version, depending on need. It includes two steel belt clips for maximum support and stability.
The Relentless Tactical magazine holder is available in black or brown leather. It can be worn inside or outside the waistband based on your preference. It is extremely light, weighing in at 2 ounces. This magazine pouch can accommodate just about any pistol magazine you could imagine.
- Lifetime warranty
- Looks great
- Made in the USA
- Fits almost any pistol magazine
- Somewhat rigid during break-in
Multi Holsters Elite Single Magazine Holster Pouch
Our fifth entry is the Multi Holsters Elite Single Magazine Holster Pouch. Despite being made out of durable Kydex, this magazine pouch is surprisingly comfortable. This mag pouch is a model-specific holder, meaning that you must select your handgun model from the list of options when ordering. They currently offer this magazine pouch for all of the most popular Sig, Springfield, and Glock handguns.
This magazine pouch is truly versatile. You can adjust the tension and the handedness of the carry clip. You can carry your spare magazine inside or outside your waistband and can even adjust the angle of this pouch for maximum comfort.
The Multi Holsters Elite is available in seven different finish options. It weighs a mere 1.87 ounces. In order to make this magazine holder more comfortable, the manufacturer smoothed out the outer edges. This also gives the product a refined appearance.
- Ambidextrous Design
- Model Specific which results in excellent retention
- Comfortable enough to wear all-day
- Multiple finish options
- Limited options for Smith and Wesson magazines
- Limited options for Ruger magazines
CREATRILL 2 Pack Magnetic Pistol Magazine Holsters
Next up is a unique magazine pouch made by CREATRILL. These pouches are made from a combination of leather and neoprene. They feature a magnetic retention system. There is a small coin magnet stitched into the fabric of these holders which helps to hold your magazine in place.
This pouch is available in three general sizes: small, medium, and large. The medium and large pouches are sold in packs of 2 while the small pouch is sold as a single item.
These pouches offer good retention and sweat resistance. They are very lightweight and are comfortable due to their soft outer shell. They are designed for IWB carriers but can be carried OWB if you prefer. They attach to your belt or waistband with a steel clip.
The CREATRILL magazine pouches weigh just over 1 ounce each. They are available in black only. They can accommodate a wide array of magazine sizes, including both single and double stack magazines.
- Magnetic retention
- Sold in packs of 2
- Virtually universal
- Can be worn IWB or OWB
- Durability concerns with heavier use
- Magnet retention is not adjustable
Universal IWB/OWB Magazine Holster
For our seventh pick, we will turn our attention back to a more traditional EDC magazine pouch. This universal IWB/OWB magazine holster is made from Kydex and is ambidextrous. It has adjustable tension for a custom feel.
This magazine pouch can accommodate the following calibers: 9mm, .40, and .45. It is available in a single stack or double stack version, making it easy to find an option no matter what your EDC pistol is.
The rigid nature of Kydex does make it a little less comfortable than some of our soft-sided options. However, you can put this magazine pouch through just about anything and it will keep on going strong.
This universal magazine holster weighs in at approximately 2 ounces. It is available in four different models, all of which include the standard black finish. The Allen wrench necessary for tension adjustments is included with your purchase.
- Durable Kydex
- Can accommodate multiple magazine sizes
- IWB or OWB carry
- Very rigid
- Can become uncomfortable throughout the day
KRYDEX Pistol Mag Pouch
Our eighth and final selection is the Krydex Pistol Mag Pouch. This unique magazine holder is made from a combination of nylon, plastic, and rubber. While it says “9mm” in the product description, this product offers a large amount of tension adjustment and can accommodate any single or double stack magazine.
If you opt for this magazine pouch, it is vital that you select one with a gun belt clip as they also offer pouches designed for MOLLE attachment. MOLLE is a modular attachment system utilized on vests and backpacks. If you are an avid outdoorsman, you can always opt for one of the Krydex pouches that include both MOLLE clips and a belt clip.
This pouch is extremely comfortable to wear due to its soft interior design and harder outer shell. It offers a good balance of durability and flexibility. They are also available in a variety of finishes in case you are looking for something other than black.
These Krydex pouches are available in 12 different finish options. They are a little heavier than some of our other options, with the largest size weighing close to 4 ounces. You will have a choice between a short and tall pouch, depending on your magazine size.
- Extremely Durable
- 12 finish options
- Unique design
- Heavier than most magazine pouches
- OWB Carry only
Guide to Buying the Best CCW Magazine Pouches and Holsters
As an avid gun owner, few things are more frustrating than wasting your money on a subpar product that does not function like it is supposed to. That is why it is important to do your research and know what features to look for when picking your CCW magazine pouch.
While all of the magazine pouches on our list are of good quality, they each include different features as every shooter’s goals and preferences are different. If you like to transition from business attire to hitting the trails, one of the Kydex options or the soft shell pouch would be ideal. On the other hand, if you primarily carry in casual settings, something that offers maximum comfort might better fit your needs.
Why Carry a Spare Magazine?
I am a firm believer in developing sound fundamentals as a shooter, especially if you intend to carry with a concealed magazine holder. Unless you work in a high-risk field or have goals of becoming a competition shooter, having a strong grasp of the basics will carry you through if you ever have to use your firearm in self-defense.
With that said, you should always carry a spare magazine. I’ll admit that the chances of you needing to reload your firearm in a self-defense scenario are low. However, it is better to have something and not need it rather than need it and not have it. Plus, an extra magazine and holder weigh in at well under a 1lb.
Not only that, but you should practice reloads with your CCW gear. You should do so from your intended carry position. It is a good idea to have your shirt untucked and covering your gear so that you get accustomed to clearing your clothing as well.
Depending on the rules of your local range, they may frown on drawing and reloading from a concealed carry position. If that is the case, you can always do drills at home with an unloaded weapon and empty magazines. At the start, focus on smooth movements, not overall speed. As my old salty range master always said, “slow is smooth, smooth is fast”.
Features You Want in a Magazine Holster
As with all types of EDC gear, it is important to get a clear idea of what your goals and intended application are.
Once you have done that, you can start narrowing down our list and look for the features that you want. Although your significant other may disagree with this approach, you can always buy two different types of pouches.
I often get my gear in both leather and Kydex because I have found that each excels in certain applications. Leather tends to offer a good mix of durability and comfort while Kydex offers the best retention.
Magazine Holster or Pouch
You have probably noticed that some products were described as holsters or holders, while others were referred to as mag pouches or magazine pouches. The two items are very similar but have one key difference, the material.
Typically, a magazine holder is referred to as a pouch if it is made from a soft or flexible material. Kydex or polymer gear is called a magazine holster and is molded for a tighter fit. As mentioned above, each has their share of benefits and are uniquely suited for certain applications.
Soft-Sided Vs Hard-Sided Magazine Carriers
The three most popular magazine pouch materials are Kydex, leather, and nylon. Leather and nylon are utilized in soft-sided mag pouches while Kydex is used for hard carriers. Some hybrid carriers, like the Krydex soft-shell, combine multiple materials.
A soft-sided nylon magazine pouch will be the most comfortable. They can easily be carried IWB without concerns of rubbing or irritation. The flexibility will also make the transition between a seated and standing position more seamless.
However, nylon holsters offer minimal retention. If you are simply wearing it during normal day-to-day errands, then this may not be a major concern. However, a lack of adequate retention can be problematic if you are hiking or engaging in more physically strenuous activities.
Leather offers much better retention and durability than nylon while still maintaining a reasonable level of comfort. The smooth finish will not cause skin irritation, even when carrying for hours on end. They are not as flexible, but look and function well. Few things look or feel more natural than a quality leather holster and matching magazine pouch.
While Kydex holsters can be carried IWB, they excel at OWB carrier. Many of them feature both adjustable tension and adjustable carry angles. I like to cant my Kydex magazine carriers slightly forward. Doing so reduces printing and also provides more rapid access under stress.
The adjustable tension allows for a custom-feel. Every shooter will want a slightly different level of retention for their magazines. You can draw the magazine and adjust accordingly until you find the right amount of tension for you. I usually tighten mine until I can hold the carrier upside down without the magazine falling out.
The major drawback to Kydex is that they can be a little uncomfortable with IWB carry. This can usually be offset by adjusting the waistband of your pants and the positioning of the carrier. However, they will still not be as comfortable as soft-sided holsters.
Know Your Local Gun Laws
The most important aspect of concealed carry is safety. You should always practice fundamental gun safety anytime you are handling a firearm. Carrying a concealed weapon is a right that also comes with a great deal of responsibility. It is important to keep in mind that you are introducing a loaded firearm everywhere you go and that you are accountable for that weapon.
The second key aspect of concealed carry is legality. Once you have a good grasp on gun safety, you must also know your local gun laws before you start carrying your weapon. Every state has unique requirements for concealed carry. Most states require that you complete a licensure process, while a handful of them do not require a permit.
Many EDC questions I get pertain to open carry. While it is legal in a few states, I do not recommend the open carrying of firearms. The goal of EDC is typically for self-defense purposes. By choosing to open carry, you are voluntarily giving up the element of surprise and putting a target on yourself.
If you have been carrying concealed for a while or just started looking into getting your permit, you have probably heard the term reciprocity. Reciprocity refers to whether or not another state honors your concealed carry permit. Typically, if your state recognizes another state’s concealed carry permit, they will also accept your permit in their state.
It is vital that you read up on reciprocity and gun laws of neighboring states before traveling through them. Unwittingly violating another state’s gun laws by carrying a weapon with too high of a magazine capacity is a great way to cause yourself a world of legal trouble. This is especially important if you plan on traveling to states such as California or New York, both of which have stringent firearms restrictions.
Can’t Beat a Classic
Despite the strengths of modern materials like Kydex, you just can’t beat a hand-made leather magazine pouch. The Relentless Tactical Leather Double Magazine Holder is both durable and versatile. The lifetime warranty and quality stitchwork result in a product that can withstand years of rugged use.
Not only that, but it is available in a single-stack and double-stack option. This means that it is one of the most universal magazine pouches on our list. No matter what size magazines your go-to carry pistol use, the Relentless Tactical magazine holder is up to the task.
This magazine pouch is not only durable, but it is comfortable enough to wear all day long without irritation. It is even available in a single pouch option if you prefer to carry only one spare. The Relentless Tactical is the last EDC mag pouch that you will ever need to buy.