Have you heard of J-frame, Chief’s Special, or the Model 36? All those refer to the classic S&W Model 36 Chief’s Special revolver.
History
Some argue that, back in the 50s, Smith and Wesson was distracted with the demand for service guns for police and military units and so neglected keeping up with Colt in the concealed carry handgun market. Colt’s Detective Special in .38 Special was a big hit and Smith and Wesson’s best answer, at the time, was their little I frame revolvers in .32 S&W Long and .38 Special rounds were just too powerful for these little guns. So Smith beefed up their I frame and came up with a revolver, only slightly larger, that could handle the harder-hitting .38 round to finally gave Colt meaningful competition in the CCW arena. The gun was unveiled at the International Association of Chiefs of Police in 1950 and the name, “Chief’s Special,” stuck. In 1957, Smith and Wesson’s new J-frame wheel gun was renamed the Model 36, but I’ll just stick with calling it the Chief’s Special for this review. The world of concealed handguns has not been the same since The Chief’s Special, and its many descendants and copies continue to be sold and carried today.
Features
The Chief’s Special is a conventional double action revolver with an exposed hammer that allows for both single action (cocking the hammer and pulling the trigger) and double action (pulling the trigger without cocking the hammer). Its also features S&W’s conventional swing-out cylinder that holds five .38 Special rounds. Finishes and grips have varied over the years, but the traditional model featuers walnut grips and a blued finish. New production models run about $700 but a good vintage model can be had for as little as $300.
Shooting
As a concealed carry gun, the Chief’s Special was designed to save lives. Its small frame and approximate 20 ounce weight is easy to tote around. The walnut grips make for a snag-free draw and fire. The grips may look small to some, but my large hands can manage a full grip—although some later J frames leave the pinky hanging, which often translates into degraded accuracy and recoil management. The weight of the all-steel firearm (21.4oz for the model featured in this review) and its three inch tapered barrel helps keep recoil of my favorite 150 grain wad cutter carry loads down for quick follow up shots.
The Chief’s Special’s sights feature a front ramped sight and a rear sight milled into the frame. These low profile, non-adjustable sights may not inspire Olympic accuracy with ease, but they are right on using 158 grain loads—lighter rounds strike lower and heavier rounds hit higher. Regardless of load, putting five rounds into a six inch pattern at both seven and twenty five yards is not hard, even when pulling that weighty double action trigger.
Final Thoughts
It can be hard to find a concealable revolver that one shoots, but I’ve found the good old Chief’s Special fits the bill very well. The design has served well enough that S&W continues producing them today. The original Model 36 design has spawned many lightweight descendants and copies from companies around the world—a lasting testament to a design to which people continue to trust their lives. The very firearm in my possession has already successfully deescalated a dangerous situation in its service as one of my concealed carry options. Accurate, lightweight, and proven concealed carry effective, the Chief’s Special design hasn’t aged a day.
Featured image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
Interesting to hear about the “I frame,” very new to me! I enjoyed the side by side comparison. My “K frame” is pretty fun to shoot at the range. Though I’m trying to put in more rounds on my “J frame,” I definitely need more practice.
p.s. Almost bought a Model 36 myself the other week. Now, I’m wishing I did!
mobilehomegurl The I frame is an interesting little gun and now I feel I can move on to that little write up. The Model 36 is still in production but the stainless Model 60 is good too. Those boot grip J frames are hard to shoot well. How do you like your J frame?
TerrilSmoothboreHebert So far, I’m enjoying the J frame. Though, after a box or two of shooting it starts to get uncomfortable. It’s good for practice but not something I can shoot all day. Looking forward to the I frame write-up!
I am surprised you didn’t bring up the Smith and Wesson Model 30 in detail, it is chambered in .32 S&W and holds 6 rounds I believe (I saw one in person, right next to a Pre-57 Chief’s Special with flat latch cylinder release and 1.875in barrel that was Mint at a Pawn shop). It looks the exact same as a 1.875in barreled Chief’s Special (Pre-57 Model 36).My Pre-57 Chief’s Special also had the flat latch but it considerable bluing wear so I sold it to purchase a G26 Gen 3 after I found that Mint Chief’s Special. I went into that shop and saw that Mint Chief’s Special which had a serial number that was about 1000 before mine, right above it was a Model 30 of around the same age and it was Mint too. I plan on purchasing both to curio on my wall. My big point I guess is that I was planning to get them to carry, the 30 as a New York Reload, instead I plan to purchase as a collection. My old Chief’s Special was my holdout piece for about 4 years until I sold it, and it was a tack driver and great back-up carry pistol. So I purchased the 26 to replace it (As that is one of the reasons Glock designed it :P) after I saw one that was mint. Here in two weeks I will have the 30 and the Chief’s Special (I collect Pre-lock S&W revolvers). I see nothing wrong with carrying them and they are a joy to shoot. I cannot wait to have both of them as show pieces :). I Carry a 19 in conjunction with a 26 (now), but I would have no problem slapping some leather on and carrying my 686-3 4 inch with a Chief’s Special as a BUG. Even solo the M36 or Chief’s Special are formidable CCDW revolvers if you have time behind them. Thank you for bringing up the distant memory of my old Chief’s Special. 🙂 I wish I could attach a Photo of it for those that read my comment.
Oh, My Chief’s special was a round butt with the original grips. The Mint one and the M30 they have are also round butt.
Z0mb3hHunt3r The review on my Model 30 is next. I wanted to use this as a precursor.
Another first class article by Mark3smle! My wife has a 637 and just loves it. It really is a good little gun and a lit more accurate than many may think. Anyways, great article and look forward to the next one.
I love the history you include in these reviews. Keep up the great work! Thanks ;D