The Arms Guide
  • Home
  • Concealed Carry
  • Firearms Training
  • Handguns
  • Rifles
  • Gun News
  • AR-15
  • Reloading Gear
  • Gun Safes

Weird Gun Wednesday: Elgin Cutlass Pistol

Weird Gun Wednesday: Elgin Cutlass Pistol

September 28, 2016 by Nate Granzow 22 Comments

Back in the early 19th century, simple, muzzle-loaded pistols were about the best you could hope for when it came to a sidearm. And that didn’t amount to much: They generally held only one round, were smoothbore (synonymous with the word ‘inaccurate’), and slow to reload. In this regard, edged-weapons such as swords or cutlasses still reigned superior for close-quarters combat. Ah, but if you could harness the range of the pistol while maintaining the dependability of the sword, you’d really be on to something. Enter the Elgin Cutlass Pistol.

Weird Gun Wednesday: Elgin Cutlass Pistol
Photo courtesy of IMFDB.

Where you’ve seen it:

In the film Gangs Of New Yorkamazon, Leonardo DiCaprio hurls a knife at Bill “The Butcher,” misses, and draws one of these awesome contraptions just before catching a blade in the gut (right). Too slow, Leonardo. Too slow.

History:

In 1837, a firearms designer named George Elgin, inspired by the exploits of frontiersman James Bowie—a man famous for his skills with a knife who had died just a year prior at The Battle of the Alamo—designed the Elgin Cutlass Pistol. The knife fighter’s influence is apparent in the Elgin’s design (something about that bowie knife hanging off the pistol’s frame). Production lasted only a year, and the total number of Elgin Cutlass Pistols produced rang in at 150. Not a lot. But what it lacked in numbers, it made up for with historical prominence: The Elgin was the first officially adopted U.S. percussion pistol, and is to this day the only formally adopted pistol/cutlass combination in U.S. history. Specifically adopted for use in the Wilkes South Seas Exploring Expedition—a four-year effort to survey the south Pacific—this unusual weapon proved its worth fighting off angry, spear-toting Pacific islanders.

The design:

The 11-inch-long bowie knife blade—with an integral trigger and knuckle guard—is attached to the underside of the octagonal-barreled pistol by a tongue and groove, and held in place with two screws. With the inclusion of the blade, the gun reaches 17 inches long. Might have had something to do with why it was perceived as a touch unwieldy. That in tandem with the fact that the Elgin was expensive to produce made its short production run a certainty.

The cartridge:

Not really a cartridge, but a muzzle-loaded .54 caliber ball. Again, because the barrel of the Elgin was smooth, accuracy was limited. But hey, if, on the off-chance you did manage to hit your target, that big, 225-grain slug could do all kinds of damage—particularly since medical treatment at the time was mostly a combination of black magic and unreservedly hacking off affected limbs.

The verdict:

The Elgin Cutlass Pistol is a natural solution to a classic problem: If you can’t hit ’em, stab ’em! This may go without saying, but given the scarcity of this pistol, if you happen to find one of these in your grandmother’s attic, don’t keep the news to yourself. They fetch anywhere from $10,000-25,000 when they emerge on the market.

Featured image courtesy of Rock Island Auction Company.

Filed Under: Handguns Tagged With: bayonet, blackpowder, cutlass, flintlock, knife, percussion, pirates, pistol, pistol knife, sword

Related Posts

  • SIG Sauer P226 Platinum Elite
    SIG Sauer P226 Platinum Elite – Taking the MK 25 to the Next Level
  • Springfield XD-S 9mm
    Springfield XD-S 9mm – Great Option for Single Stack Nines
  • SIG P227 Nitron
    SIG P227 – a .45 in the Body of a 9mm

About the Author

Avatar for Nate Granzow

Nate Granzow A magazine editor and novelist by trade, Nate has spent years collecting and shooting antique, relic, and modern sporting arms, competing in cowboy-action and long-range blackpowder shoots, shooting trap/sporting clays, reloading, and hunting. He's a staunch believer that the second amendment of the U.S. Constitution is the foundation upon which all other rights are predicated, and is a strong proponent of concealed carry. Check out his novels at www.nategranzow.com.

See All Nate Granzow Articles

Comments

  1. Avatar for Nate Granzowhartcreek says

    August 8, 2013 at 5:14 pm

    Oh yea and I forgot….I own a smooth bore pepperbox in .36 cal and it is plenty accurate out to 50 feet so within a certain range I am not worried about smooth bores.  It might even make an interesting CCW because one does not need a permit to carry it and when done shooting it makes one heck of a club.

    Reply
  2. Avatar for Nate GranzowRev2DaLimit says

    August 8, 2013 at 10:02 pm

    This is just plain awesome! You’ve redefined “hump day” for me. Thanks!

    Reply
    • Avatar for Nate GranzowNateGranzow says

      August 8, 2013 at 10:07 pm

      Rev2DaLimit Aww, shucks, buddy. Thank you!

      Reply
« Older Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In Case You Missed It

The 7 Best Fireproof Gun Safes For Your Money Featured
Gun Safes

The 7 Best Fireproof Gun Safes for Your Money

January 19, 2021

Best Ar 10 Lowers Featured
Rifles

Best AR-10 Lowers (2021)

January 19, 2021

Best Sig Sauer P365 Holsters Featured
Handguns

Best Sig Sauer P365 Holsters

January 19, 2021

Best Ar 10 Upper Receiver
Rifles

6 Best AR-10 Upper Receivers – A Buyers Guide

January 11, 2021

© Copyright 2021 Thearmsguide · All Rights Reserved.

  • Comms Check
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com.